SAN JOSE, Calif. — A Santa Clara County deputy public defender says a federal immigration agent pepper-sprayed him in the face while he was filming an arrest outside the county's Hall of Justice in downtown San Jose, and San Jose police say they are now investigating the formal complaint he filed on Monday, November 16. David Oyer told NBC Bay Area he was on a sidewalk near the Santa Clara County Main Jail and the Hall of Justice when agents from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained a man, a confrontation broke out, and an agent sprayed him. The incident itself happened on Friday, November 13, at around 11:30 a.m. on West Hedding Street, according to the Mercury News, which covered it the same day.

Source: San Francisco Inquirer

"Excruciating," Oyer told NBC Bay Area. "It was probably the worst thing I've ever felt. I've broken bones and had surgeries. It's like your eyes are on fire for hours." He was treated at a hospital, where, he said, staff flushed his eyes with fluid from an IV bag. On Monday he went to the San Jose Police Department to file a formal complaint against the agents. "I think I was assaulted," he told the station. "I'd like to see due process take its course and for the individuals involved to be held accountable."

Source: NBC Bay Area via San Francisco Inquirer

Nov. 13, ~11:30 a.m.When and where the spraying is reported to have happened — West Hedding Street, San Jose
4–5 agentsMasked ICE agents the public defender's office says chased the man
Nov. 16Day Oyer filed his formal complaint with San Jose police
~1 monthHow long the office says agents have staged outside the Hall of Justice and county jail

The public defender's office account of the chase and the spray

In written answers to the San Francisco Inquirer early Wednesday, Miguel Rodriguez, an assistant public defender responding on behalf of Chief Assistant Public Defender Sarah McCarthy, gave the office's account. Oyer and another attorney had left the Hall of Justice after court appearances and were getting into their car, parked in front of the courthouse, when they saw a man running from the building with four or five masked ICE agents chasing him, Rodriguez wrote. The agents tackled the man, who screamed for help, according to the office. Oyer joined other people who had gathered to watch and record, and "recorded from a safe distance," Rodriguez wrote.

After the man was taken into custody, the office says, several agents began engaging with the onlookers and became aggressive. "With no warning an ICE Agent removed pepper spray and sprayed towards the crowd and directly into Mr. Oyer's eyes," Rodriguez wrote. The Mercury News account, as summarised in later reporting, says two public defender attorneys and members of the civil rights group Silicon Valley De-Bug — who were nearby conducting outreach about a surge in ICE activity around local courthouses — started recording after agents chased and tackled the man, that agents pushed to clear space after the man was handcuffed, and that two attorneys and at least two De-Bug members were hit, with one attorney and one activist needing hospital treatment. Oyer told NBC Bay Area he had seen agents push one onlooker, "maybe pushing to try to disengage," before "out of nowhere the ICE agent grabbed his pepper spray," and that he said nothing to provoke the agents and did not interfere with the arrest.

"Disgusting and reprehensible" — and a courthouse already on edge

"We find the actions of the ICE agents to be disgusting and reprehensible," Rodriguez wrote. Agents "have staged outside of the Hall of Justice and County Jail for the past month," he said, and the office believes their behavior "has grown increasingly aggressive and violent." The county's chief public defender, Damon Silver, said he was "saddened, though unfortunately not surprised," and that the incident "raises serious concerns about the safety of attorneys, court staff, litigants, and community members."

The office says the presence itself is doing damage before any spray is used. Their tactics "are interfering with the administration of justice as defendants, witnesses and victims are afraid to come to court," Rodriguez wrote. He also said agents had detained U.S. citizens, including a Latino attorney with the public defender's office — a claim the Inquirer said it has not independently confirmed and for which the office provided no details, so it is reported here as the office's allegation only. The office has told its own lawyers how to behave around enforcement actions: "All attorneys have been advised to not interact with ICE agents and maintain a safe distance if recording what they believe might be unlawful conduct of ICE agents," Rodriguez wrote, adding that Oyer was following those directions when he was sprayed.

Why a courthouse arrest matters to anyone with a court date

A courthouse is one of the few places people cannot simply choose to avoid: defendants, witnesses and victims who miss a date can face warrants, lost cases or worse. That is why enforcement activity staged outside a Hall of Justice draws a different kind of scrutiny from a street operation — lawyers argue that if people become afraid to walk into court, the court system itself stops working, for citizens and non-citizens alike. For immigrant families across Santa Clara County and the wider Bay Area — including Punjabi diaspora readers with family members in immigration, criminal or family court — the San Jose investigation is a concrete local test of where the line around courthouse enforcement actually sits.

An investigation with obstacles, and no federal account so far

San Jose police told NBC Bay Area in an email that they were collecting evidence and that the circumstances of the incident were under investigation, and the public defender's office says police told it the same. Rodriguez warned that any investigation "will be complicated by the fact that the ICE agents wear mask, will not identify themselves upon request or provide a badge number and are travelling in vehicles with no license plates." Mike Leininger, a retired San Jose police investigator who works as a law enforcement analyst, told NBC Bay Area that Oyer was likely to run into what he called a federal roadblock. "There's going to be a problem," Leininger said. "The federal government has consistently not cooperated with local law enforcement." He added: "Their escalation seems to go up rapidly. I don't see very many de-escalation tactics being employed, and it seems that pepper spray is often their go-to."

There is also a legal obstacle that reporting on the case has flagged: federal officers acting within the scope of their duties can claim immunity from state prosecution under the U.S. Constitution's supremacy clause, a defence that has made state charges against federal agents rare, and it is not clear what evidence San Jose police have been able to gather about the agent involved. On the federal side, ICE and the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees it, have not given a public account of the encounter. NBC Bay Area said it had asked both agencies for comment and had not immediately heard back; the Inquirer emailed ICE's press office on Tuesday with the same questions and received no response by publication, and the San Jose mayor's office and the ACLU of Northern California had also not responded to the Inquirer by publication.

What happens next

The man whose arrest Oyer was recording has not been publicly identified, and it is not known what immigration or criminal charges, if any, he faces. What is verified so far is narrow: a deputy public defender says he was sprayed while filming from a distance; his office's written account describes an unprovoked spray into a crowd; he was treated in hospital and filed a police complaint three days later; San Jose police say an investigation is under way; and the federal agencies involved have said nothing publicly. The next developments to watch are whether San Jose police identify the agent involved or refer any finding to prosecutors, whether ICE or DHS issues the account it has so far withheld, and whether the public defender's office — which says agents have been staged outside the courthouse for a month — takes the fight to court or to county government.