DENVER, Colorado — A federal judge in Denver on Wednesday, November 18, held U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Department of Homeland Security officials in contempt of court for repeatedly violating judicial orders by re-detaining immigrants minutes after judges had ordered them released, Colorado Public Radio (CPR) reported. U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney issued the finding in a 15-page written ruling that CPR described as an excoriation of top Colorado ICE and DHS officials — and as a stern warning that court orders in detention cases must be read and obeyed, or greater punishment may follow.

Source: Colorado Public Radio, Nov. 18, 2026

“ICE’s new ‘policy’ of immediately re-detaining petitioners following release made a mockery of court orders mandating petitioners’ immediate release,” Judge Sweeney wrote. “Lest there be any confusion: All orders and judgments of courts must be complied with promptly … This is neither a novel nor complex statement to comprehend.” She added, citing a 1979 case: “Our system of jurisprudence rests on the assumption that all individuals, whatever their position in government, are subject to federal law. No man is above the law.”

The ruling is the decision Awaaz Punjab's earlier reporting said was coming. This desk reported on November 4 that Judge Sweeney had opened an inquiry after an ICE supervisor testified to receiving a “direct order” to re-arrest freed detainees, and on November 9 that acting Denver ICE director Nathan Rasper had admitted under oath that the re-arrest instruction was his, with the judge saying a written order would decide the contempt question. Wednesday's 15-page order is that decision: the conduct was contempt. Because the government had already stopped the practice, however, the judge imposed no fine and ordered no further sanction this time.

15 pagesLength of Judge Sweeney's written contempt ruling, issued Wednesday, November 18
At least 18People in Colorado re-arrested within minutes of a judge-ordered release, or held longer than they should have been, in the past six weeks, per CPR; immigration attorneys estimate the true number is higher
Oct. 27Date Ramon Quintero Alvarez was released from ICE custody — and immediately re-detained after taking a few steps
Nov. 4Date ICE's Denver leadership says the immediate re-arrest practice was stopped, testimony the judge credited in declining further action

The case that started it: Ramon Quintero Alvarez

The case in front of Judge Sweeney is Quintero Alvarez v. Baltazar, No. 1:26-cv-04891 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado. Ramon Quintero Alvarez was born in Mexico and entered the United States with his mother between 1993 and 1994; he told the judge he has lived in Wyoming for 12 years with his two American-born sons and has not left the United States since arriving more than 30 years ago, CPR reported. The federal government, represented by the Colorado U.S. Attorney's Office led by Peter McNeilly, did not challenge those facts and failed to show cause by October 27 why Alvarez should not be let out of detention. He was released from immigration custody — and was immediately re-detained after he took a few steps in freedom. Judge Sweeney said that was unlawful.

Alvarez had been held at the privately run ICE detention facility in Aurora, Colorado. His habeas corpus petition — the legal mechanism by which a detained person asks a federal judge to decide whether the government may lawfully keep them in custody — was filed without a lawyer. After the October 27 release-and-re-detention, Judge Sweeney ordered him freed again, opened the wider inquiry, and summoned ICE's Denver leadership to explain a practice that, by the government's own count at the November 9 hearing, had reached at least 18 people.

What ICE officials told the court under oath

Nichole Black, the assistant field office director for ICE's Enforcement and Removal Operations in Denver, told Judge Sweeney she had “received a direct order” from her supervisor that she could “re-detain” immigrants “that had some type of criminality.” In the ruling, the judge wrote: “Ms. Black said in her own words that she believed it was permissible to simply escort someone to a public area and immediately re-detain them despite a court order to the contrary. This should — and in the court's opinion, must — shock any reader.” Black's supervisor, acting field office director Nathan Rasper, told the judge he believed he was under an obligation to “make lawful arrests” and had heard that people could be re-arrested based on a policy in Minnesota, CPR reported.

What saved the government from heavier consequences, the judge wrote, was that testimony: Rasper told a visibly frustrated Judge Sweeney at the hearing earlier this month that he had stopped re-arresting people who were ordered released. “Given the (government) cured the contempt by ceasing the practice at issue, the court declines to take any further action,” she wrote. Judges holding officials in contempt can impose fines or order behaviour stopped; Wednesday's ruling stopped short of those reliefs and functioned mainly as a formal scolding from a co-equal branch — with an explicit warning that further violations could reopen the matter.

Background: habeas orders, other judges, and the government's position

Colorado is not the only place the release-then-re-arrest pattern has surfaced, and Judge Sweeney is not the only Denver judge who reacted. As Awaaz Punjab reported earlier this month, Judges Gordon P. Gallagher and Philip A. Brimmer rewrote their release orders to bar quick re-arrests, and Judge S. Kato Crews barred ICE from re-arresting one man, Edgardo Garcia Vargas, unless the government first proved at a bond hearing that he was a flight risk or a danger. The Department of Homeland Security's stated position, in a November 6 statement reported in earlier coverage, is that a judge's release order does not immunise a person from later immigration enforcement and that ICE may re-arrest a person in a way that complies with the judicial decision. Judge Sweeney's ruling rejects the version of that argument used in Colorado: a release measured in steps or minutes, she held, is not compliance at all.

Why this matters to diaspora families

For Punjabi and other immigrant families in Colorado and across the United States with a relative in ICE detention, Wednesday's ruling makes the wording of a release order decisive. An order that bars re-arrest without a prior bond hearing — and puts the burden on the government to prove flight risk or danger — is far harder to sidestep than a bare release order. Families should keep an immigration lawyer engaged after any habeas win and ask counsel about those protections before release day. This is general information, not legal advice.

What happens next

U.S. Attorney Peter McNeilly, who attended at least one of the recent hearings before frustrated federal judges as a spectator, had no comment on Wednesday on Judge Sweeney's order, CPR reported. The contempt finding itself is now closed unless violations recur: the judge declined further action because the practice had stopped, while making clear she would not hesitate to reopen it. The underlying immigration cases — including Alvarez's — continue on their own tracks; a habeas release, and now a contempt ruling, decide how detention is handled, not whether a person's immigration case succeeds. Immigration attorneys say the count of people affected in Colorado may still rise above 18, because many detainees represent themselves and their re-arrests may never have been put before a judge.

What is solid

  • Judge Charlotte Sweeney held ICE and DHS officials in contempt in a 15-page written ruling on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, over the immediate re-detention of people judges had ordered released in Colorado (CPR, reporting the ruling).
  • At least 18 people in Colorado were re-arrested within minutes of a court-ordered release or held longer than they should have been in the past six weeks; the government itself gave the court the figure of at least 18 at the November 9 hearing.
  • The judge imposed no fine and took no further action, writing that the government had cured the contempt by ceasing the practice; acting Denver ICE director Nathan Rasper testified he ordered the practice stopped on November 4.

What is only claimed

  • DHS maintains, in its November 6 statement, that a release order does not permanently shield a person from immigration enforcement and that ICE may re-arrest in compliance with a judicial decision; Judge Sweeney held that the immediate re-arrests in Colorado did not comply.
  • Immigration attorneys estimate the number of people affected is higher than 18 because many detainees represent themselves; no court-verified total above 18 has been published.