The lead defendant in the federal 'Michigan 12' threats case has been charged by a grand jury with tampering with evidence, as prosecutors allege she tried to destroy a laptop while agents were forcing their way into the Detroit townhouse she shared with a co-defendant. Zainaib Hakim was charged on Wednesday, November 18, with one count of tampering with evidence and committing an offence while on release, U.S. Attorney Jerome F. Gorgon announced in Detroit.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice, Eastern District of Michigan
Wednesday's charge is a major new development, not a repeat of the earlier court fight. Prosecutors first raised the laptop allegation in a November 2 court motion asking a judge to jail Hakim while she awaited trial — a motion this newsroom reported on November 5. A grand jury has now turned that allegation into a formal criminal count: the new superseding indictment adds an 11th count to the existing 10-count indictment against the 12 defendants.
Source: The Detroit News reporting, via Zeale summary of the Nov 2 filing
A wet laptop under a bed
According to the prosecutors' earlier filing, reported by The Detroit News, the allegation centres on an October 29 law-enforcement operation. Officials preparing to arrest co-defendant Henry David MacKeen-Shapiro and co-defendant Aaron Hunter Vonbargen, 25, called one of Vonbargen's relatives to notify them of his arrest warrant. Agents then forced entry into the Detroit townhouse Hakim shares with MacKeen-Shapiro after she and two others inside failed to open the door.
Inside, investigators found a wet laptop concealed by bags of clothing beneath Hakim's bed. "The sabotaged MacBook had been recently dunked in water," prosecutors wrote, according to The Detroit News. "Droplets remained on the screen and touchpad. All evidence points to Zainab Hakim either being tipped off by a conspirator, or hearing the police knock and announce, and destroying (or attempting to destroy) and hiding MacKeen-Shapiro's laptop computer." Wednesday's indictment states that Hakim attempted to destroy the laptop and impair its use in the case pending against her, MacKeen-Shapiro and the 10 other defendants.
Hakim's attorney, Amanda Bashi, has disputed the government's account, telling The Detroit News in an email that they "strongly contest" the allegations and looked forward to filing a response. Hakim was ordered released in June on a $10,000 unsecured bond by U.S. Magistrate Judge Anthony Patti, who concluded that restrictions could reasonably address concerns about public safety and her appearance in court — which is why the new count also charges her with committing an offence while on release.
"It has long been said that 'one crime has to be concealed by another,'" U.S. Attorney Jerome F. Gorgon said. "These allegations are alarming because an attempt to tamper with evidence undermines the judicial process."
The underlying 'Michigan 12' case
The 12 defendants are accused of a conspiracy that began after the October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorist attacks on Israel. Court documents state that the defendants and unindicted conspirators used encrypted messages, social media and overseas collaboration platforms to research, target and attack people and businesses they perceived to be sympathetic to Israel, with the goal of forcing the University of Michigan and other businesses to sever all perceived ties with the State of Israel.
Their alleged attacks included spray-painting threats, breaking windows, staging the front yard of a victim's private residence to resemble a mass grave, and throwing glass jars filled with noxious chemicals into family homes. The defendants allegedly marked victims with threatening symbols used by Hamas, including red inverted triangles meant to communicate that the victim is marked for death, and followed up with social-media posts carrying additional threats and warnings. Prosecutors say the campaign ran from about October 2023 through April 2025 and targeted University of Michigan leaders, regents and a university police lieutenant, the Jewish Federation of Detroit, a student and two businesses.
What happens next
Hakim will be arraigned on the new count in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, where the underlying case, United States v. Hakim, is pending before Judge Judith E. Levy. Prosecutors' separate bid to revoke her release and jail her pending trial — the November 2 motion built on the same laptop allegation — remains part of the court fight, and her defence has said it will answer it in court. An indictment is only a charge and is not evidence of guilt: Hakim is presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and it is the government's burden to prove guilt. No trial date for the 12-defendant case was announced in Wednesday's release.
