ST. PAUL, Minn. — The fight between St. Paul's mayor and her own police chief is now fully joined in court. In a lengthy response filed Monday, November 16, Mayor Kaohly Her denied many of the allegations in the sexual harassment lawsuit Police Chief Axel Henry filed against her, and the City of St. Paul filed a separate response denying his claims against the city. Henry's lawsuit, filed in September — on September 23, according to the case record reported by the Minnesota Star Tribune — alleges sexual harassment and battery and claims the city retaliated against him when he reported the conduct. Every allegation in the suit remains just that, an allegation, and the mayor's filing asks the court to dismiss the complaint.
Source: Minnesota Star Tribune via Police1
Her's own answer runs to 68 pages and goes through Henry's lawsuit paragraph by paragraph, disputing each claim, FOX 9 reported. In it, she argues that her professional relationship with Henry deteriorated over disagreements involving immigration enforcement (ICE), police department oversight and budgeting — not over the alleged harassment — and she questions Henry's characterization of their interactions throughout.
Source: FOX 9 via MinnMix
What the outside investigation found — and what it did not
Before the lawsuit, the city funded an investigation by an outside law firm. Attorneys hired by the city wrote in their response that Her's actions do not rise to the level of sexual harassment and were not 'severe and pervasive,' noting that the third-party investigator did not substantiate the allegations of sexual harassment, retaliation or creating an 'uncomfortable work environment.' At the same time, the investigation did substantiate narrower findings: that the mayor made suggestive jokes about 'wieners,' photoshopped the heads of male police officers onto shirtless bodybuilders, commented on female employees' breasts, and that a witness corroborated that she touched Henry's leg during a meeting — while concluding those incidents did not constitute sexual harassment.
The consequences so far are administrative, not legal. In past statements, Her has apologized for what she called misguided 'attempts at humor.' The city's human resources department is requiring her to complete sexual harassment training and to hire an executive coach at her own expense. Susan M. Tindal, an attorney for the law firm representing St. Paul, said in a statement that the city 'denies the claims and remains committed to continuing to operate in the city's best interest and to have the police department and mayor's office work collaboratively.' Henry's attorney, Chris Madel, declined to comment.
Claim by claim: the cigar lounge, the gym and the photographs
Henry's lawsuit alleges that in December he and the mayor met at a cigar lounge with Todd Hurley, president of the St. Paul Port Authority, to discuss potentially moving the police station downtown to attract more businesses, and that Her allegedly told Henry that if she did not get her way, she would just tell people that Hurley 'grabbed her ass.' The city admits the two went to a cigar lounge but says it is 'without information to admit or deny the remainder,' and notes that at the end of December Henry 'gifted Mayor Her a cigar holder.'
That same month, the mayor began working out at the gym at police headquarters and, Henry alleges, repeatedly commented on several high-ranking officers being 'so beefy.' The city admitted only that 'the third-party investigation report indicated Mayor Her made comments about officers being beefy.' On the photographs, the outside investigation substantiated that Her created and shared inappropriate photos depicting scantily clad officers. The city admitted someone helped Her get into Henry's office, and that she photoshopped images of officers as UFC fighters, boy-band singers and body builders with 'prominent bulges' in their crotch area and put them in his office. The city denied the photoshopped boy-band photo was 'inappropriate or undermining,' but admitted Her's conduct was inappropriate, and said it is 'without information to admit or deny bulges' in the photos. In Her's own filing, she says Henry had allowed her access, that she was on the department's sixth floor with a police escort, and that Henry never complained about the altered photographs at the time — she says he told her he found them funny and wanted to keep them.
The 'MILF' claim, the meme and the bar meeting
Henry's lawsuit accused Her of describing herself as a 'MILF,' a sexually vulgar acronym. The city responded that the outside investigation said Her did not recall referring to herself that way and 'does not think she is a MILF.' FOX 9's account of the filing adds the detail behind the claim: Henry alleges that at a police ceremony in February, Her asked what the initials 'MFF' on one of his ribbons stood for, was told they meant Mobile Field Force, and claims she replied, 'Oh, I thought it said MILF so maybe I could get one.' Her denies ever making the joke, and denies another comment at the same ceremony that Henry interpreted as sexual innuendo.
On the meme, the mayor has been accused of sending a city employee a text reading 'Happy Weiner Wednesday!' with a note regretting she could not be with the employee to eat a hot dog that day, above an internet meme — created by the content creator Savage Dynasty — showing a swaddled baby with an adult's head and a caption about 'a good weinering.' The city denied the mayor added the message in the text, noting she 'added a different picture to the meme,' while the outside investigator found the meme Her sent was 'sexual in nature and inappropriate.' In her filing, Her says she did not come up with the name 'Weiner Wednesday,' which she says was long used for a weekly police department event, and that the 'weinering' wording was not something she wrote.
The police chief's lawsuit also describes a Saturday night meeting at a St. Paul bar, Sweeney's Saloon, where he alleges Her talked about marriage problems and offered to drive him home, and claims she told him he needed to choose between being her friend, being just an employee or colleague, or 'go.' The city admitted Henry and Her met at Sweeney's and that 'something similar to the allegations occurred' during the meeting, but denied a 'sexual request or sexual relationship,' and noted Henry said 'something about being Mayor Her's friend and he was friends with the previous mayor and he made a comment about it being weird.' Her's filing disputes that she discouraged him from bringing his partner — she says she told him his partner was welcome — denies she consumed a THC beverage at the bar, saying she only had a nonalcoholic drink, and denies offering Henry a ride home, saying her city driver had driven her to the bar.
The touching allegation at the centre of the suit
Henry alleges that Her inappropriately touched his upper thigh twice during a budget meeting in March. In her response, Her denies the physical contact but admits she moved her chair closer to Henry during the meeting to get closer to the presentation screen. The city, however, acknowledges that someone saw Her touch Henry's leg during the meeting, while stating that its investigation 'did not substantiate a determination that the touch was sexual in nature.' That gap — a corroborated touch, a denied intent, and a legal conclusion that depends on how a court weighs both — is the core dispute a judge will eventually have to resolve.
In St. Paul, as in most American cities, the police chief serves under the mayor — which makes a sitting chief suing a sitting mayor for harassment and retaliation an extraordinary breakdown at the top of a city's public-safety leadership. The filings also show the dispute is not only about personal conduct: Her's answer says the relationship broke down over immigration enforcement, police oversight and the department budget, the three issues that decide how a capital city's police force actually operates. Until a court rules, both officials remain in their jobs, and the department they are fighting over still has to be run day to day.
What happens next
A trial date has yet to be set in the case, which is being overseen by Judge Leonardo Castro. The next steps are procedural: Henry's side can reply to the dismissal request, the court will decide whether any claims are trimmed or thrown out, and the case would then move toward evidence exchange and, only later, a trial or settlement talks. For now, the verified position is narrow and should be reported exactly: a police chief has alleged harassment, battery and retaliation; a mayor and a city have formally denied the major claims and pointed to an outside investigation that substantiated inappropriate conduct but not, in their reading, sexual harassment; and an HR-ordered training and coaching requirement is the only consequence imposed so far.
