WASHINGTON — Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin faced the sharpest congressional questioning of his tenure on Wednesday, November 18, as lawmakers on the House Homeland Security Committee pressed him over investigations into people killed by federal immigration officers — and Mullin repeatedly refused to discuss them, saying the investigations are ongoing and are not his to direct.
Source: Associated Press
The session was the committee's annual worldwide-threats hearing, titled “Worldwide Threats to the Homeland: 25 Years After 9/11” and announced on November 14 by Chairman Andrew Garbarino, a New York Republican. Mullin testified alongside Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton and FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia. The Associated Press noted the hearing was also the first opportunity for Democrats to grill the Cabinet official at the centre of President Donald Trump's mass-deportation agenda since their midterm drubbing of Republicans.
“I can talk about the angel families”
The testiest exchange came when Pablo José Hernández, Puerto Rico's resident commissioner in Congress, asked Mullin for the status of investigations into the deaths of Renee Nicole Good and Alex Pretti, who were killed by Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Border Patrol officers in January amid the administration's immigration crackdown. Hernández also asked about Ruben Ray Martinez, about Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero, who was killed in July in Maine, and about Lorenzo Salgado Araujo, fatally shot by an immigration officer shortly after Guerrero in Texas, and he questioned whether the department was making sure the cases were being investigated promptly and independently.
Source: Associated Press
“I cannot talk about ongoing investigations, but I can talk about the angel families,” Mullin replied, using the term the Trump administration uses for relatives of people killed by someone in the country illegally. “Does that justify the killings?” Hernández demanded. Mullin began to answer that it never justifies it, and Hernández cut back: “Why do you have to bring up that comparison? That is very disrespectful to those people.” At another point in the exchange, Mullin snapped, “I don't know if you're hard of hearing, but I've said this multiple times,” and he insisted, “I'm not in charge of the investigation,” objecting to the way the questions were framed.
Source: Opera News / AP reporting
The confrontation did not end there. Representative Al Green of Texas told Mullin to his face that he “ought to be arrested” for what Green called a cover-up in the Pretti case. According to Raw Story's account of the hearing, the FBI is leading a federal civil rights investigation into Pretti's killing, with Homeland Security Investigations assisting, and as of the hearing no agent had been charged. Green contrasted that pace with a September 20 shooting in Austin, where an ICE officer shot Wilber Rafael Garces Perez and federal prosecutors charged Perez himself with assaulting a federal officer within days.
Source: Raw Story via The Rothman Report
The January deaths behind the questions
Good, a Minneapolis resident, was shot and killed on January 7 by an ICE agent in Minneapolis, a killing that prompted nationwide protests. Pretti, a Minneapolis nurse, was shot on January 24 by two Border Patrol agents during a protest against federal immigration enforcement. The Associated Press reported that lawmakers at the hearing also raised questions about fatal encounters, shortened training and incomplete vetting as ICE moves to recruit thousands of additional officers and agents. In his prepared statement, Mullin named four priorities for his department: border security, public safety and counterterrorism, critical infrastructure security, and economic security.
The FBI director's empty chair
Before the immigration clash, the hearing opened with a bipartisan complaint about who was not there. Chairman Garbarino said the committee had made repeated efforts to line up FBI Director Kash Patel's appearance, but Patel had made it clear “he had no intention” of being present — a significant departure from committee precedent, Garbarino said. The committee's top Democrat, Representative Bennie Thompson, joined in the criticism. The FBI sent Deputy Director Christopher Raia in Patel's place.
A football flight, a ground stop, and a week of outages
Thompson also faulted Mullin for flying to a college football game shortly after a nationwide ground stop stranded travellers. “While Americans were stranded in airports across the country, with many sleeping on the floor at their gates, the secretary boarded a luxury jet, flew to a college football game and visited the private suite of a company that DHS had awarded a $2.2 billion contract,” Thompson said. Mullin defended the LSU–Texas trip: it had been planned for weeks so he could take his nieces, he was meeting the governor there, the ground stop had been lifted before his flight, he is required to fly on government planes and he personally paid for the trip. Canceling, he argued, could have sent a confusing message of distrust in flying. He said the whole of government responded to the ground stop and got planes back in the air within hours. On the week's wider technology outages — which hit Microsoft, the Federal Aviation Administration, banking, United Airlines and a classified internal network at the National Security Agency — intelligence director Clayton told the committee the disruptions are “not a coordinated or state-sponsored attack” and appear to be separate incidents tied to maintenance and technical changes. Asked by Representative Seth Magaziner about Nvidia chip export controls to China, Mullin disavowed any role: “This wasn't something I'm dealing with. It's outside of my lane.”
Every investigation Hernández named remains ongoing, and Mullin told the committee he is not the official conducting them — so the next public answers are expected from the investigating agencies, not from the secretary's office. Politically, the oversight fight is set to intensify: Democrats won both chambers in the November 3 midterms, the new Congress convenes on January 3, 2027, and Democratic committee leaders have announced plans to subpoena Mullin and other Trump immigration officials and to investigate ICE's hiring surge and enforcement conduct.
For Punjabi and other immigrant families across the United States — including the truckers, students and small-business owners who make up much of this site's readership — Wednesday's hearing mattered because it was the accountability system working in public: the official who runs the department behind the raids was required, on the record, to answer for deaths that happened during them. His answer, repeated in several forms, was that the investigations will speak for themselves. Whether they do — and how quickly — is now the question hanging over the department as a new, Democratic-led Congress prepares to take over the questioning in January.
