Democratic Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan fired back on Wednesday, November 18, at a Trump-appointed U.S. attorney who suggested her remarks about congressional oversight could amount to a crime, calling his threat of investigation “baseless” and demanding he withdraw his letter immediately.
Source: NBC News
What Slotkin wrote
“I made those statements consistent with my basic right to freedom of speech, a right that every American enjoys under the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution,” Slotkin wrote in her letter to Reitz, obtained by NBC News. “In addition to my First Amendment rights, as a United States Senator, oversight is an important constitutional responsibility.”
“The Constitution's Speech or Debate clause bars prosecution of a legislator for conducting an investigation or performing other legislative acts,” she wrote. “As such, your threat of investigation is baseless, and you should withdraw your letter immediately.” She responded late Wednesday with a video message as well as the letter.
“Your threats are frivolous and a violation of your ethical duties as an attorney. I reserve all rights to take appropriate actions in the future as it relates to this sham investigation.” — Sen. Elissa Slotkin, in her letter to U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz
Why she called it a publicity stunt
Slotkin said Reitz's “public threats” violated Justice Department policy, and that his decision to post the letter publicly on social media rather than send it to her, her attorney or Senate legal counsel “is evidence that your threat of investigation is more about publicity and your political ambitions than any sort of legitimate inquiry.” Reitz told NBC News this week that he was “not interested in chilling free speech.”
Source: The Hill
“Exercising the power of a U.S. Attorney because you do not like my ‘political association, activities, or beliefs’ is also prohibited by the Justice Manual — and more importantly by the First Amendment and by the very criminal laws you mistakenly cited in your threat,” she wrote. In her video message, Slotkin said she was being targeted “because I said aloud in a podcast that if you violate the law or waste taxpayer dollars, you should be held accountable.”
Who is Aaron Reitz — and who else got a letter
Reitz, 39, previously worked as chief of staff for Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, and became U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas over the summer after placing fourth in the Republican primary for Texas attorney general. He has posted letters on X to five Democratic members of Congress: Slotkin, Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, Sen. Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, Sen. Adam Schiff of California and Rep. Robert Garcia of California.
In one of the letters, Reitz suggested that Slotkin's comments about congressional oversight potentially acting as a “deterrence message” to people considering joining the Trump administration could amount to a criminal civil rights offense. In his letter to Slotkin, Reitz wrote that her comments “sounds potentially illegal to me.” Legal experts have questioned that reading. Reitz has described his work as a preliminary inquiry and has not announced a formal criminal investigation.
Source: Political.org
Reitz's letters to Democratic lawmakers — including a preservation letter to Sen. Elizabeth Warren — were reported earlier. Read the earlier report
The earlier video — and the indictment attempt that failed
Slotkin and five other sitting Democratic lawmakers were separately targeted by the Trump administration earlier this year over a video they posted to social media reminding members of the military and intelligence communities that they should not obey unlawful orders. Allies of U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia Jeanine Pirro tried to indict the six Democrats for their speech in that video, but federal grand jurors unanimously rejected the indictment attempt.
Slotkin's attorney, former U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara, had previously written to Attorney General Todd Blanche cautioning him against following President Donald Trump's public instruction to look into Slotkin's political speech, which the president had dubbed a “criminal act.” Blanche has since conceded that Slotkin's words alone were “absolutely not a crime” and said at a press conference last week that there were “no ongoing investigations, criminal investigations, into words that incoming senators or congressmen have said.”
What happens next
Slotkin has reserved the right to take further action, and Reitz has not publicly responded to her demand to withdraw the letter. The standoff now sits with the Justice Department: whether it presses any inquiry into sitting members of Congress over their speech, or lets the matter drop after its own attorney general said the words alone were not a crime.
